Heritage Crusades: Saving the Past from the Commons
Type
journal article
Year
2017
The early 2014 bombing in Cairo that severely damaged the newly renovated Islamic Art Museum was reported as part of a list of incidents that indicated the precarious state of cultural heritage in the Middle East. In light of such events, this article queries the following: does the cultural heritage of the Middle East need saving? If so, by, from and for whom? In exploring the moral discourses and political motivations that anchor such calls for intervention, I examine how notions of care manifest themselves in heritage practice. In response to the moral outrage that often accompanies acts of cultural destruction, this research suggests the possible expansion of the ethical framework by which the material past becomes part of social life. Through an investigation into local engagement with artefacts and historical sites, specifically the sabbakhin in Egypt and contemporary agriculturalists in northern Syria, I describe forms of vernacular heritage linked to unstated assertions to the commons. At stake is a reframing of the hegemonic discourses of heritage management, one that often reads such activities as mere materialism unable to cultivate the correct cosmopolitan disposition for how the past should be valued. Ultimately, this article highlights the risk in overstating ideological forms of destruction as the cultural norm associated with Muslim societies. 

Keywords: Egyptology; Islam; archaeology; commons; heritage; iconoclasm
Citation
Straughn, Ian B. "Heritage Crusades: Saving the Past from the Commons." In International Journal of Islamic Architecture, Volume 6, Number 2 (pp. 367-386) , edited by Stephennie Mulder, Bristol: Intellect, 2017.
Collections
Copyright
Intellect
Country
Egypt
Language
English
Keywords
iconoclasm